Search :     
Articles » Skeletal

2004-03-25-14 Absence of fibula type II © Cuillier

Absence of fibula, type II

Dr Cuillier F., Dr Cartault F., Dr Lemaire P..

 Department of Gynecology, Félix Guyon Hospital, 97400 Saint-Denis, Réunion Island, France.
 Department of Genetic, Félix Guyon Hospital, 97400 Saint-Denis, Réunion Island, France.
 Echographic consulting room, Moufia Street, 97400 Saint-Denis, Réunion, France.
Tel : 0262 90 55 40. Fax : 0262 90 77 30.

With the use of high resolution ultrasound, there has been an increased awareness of exceptional, but detectable skeletal malformation syndromes. Nevertheless a correct diagnosis is essential for genetic counseling, for pediatric orthopedic counseling and management of the pregnancy 1-2. Recently, congenital absence of fibula condition was detected by high resolution ultrasound at 24 weeks in a fetus without family history.

Case report:
A 25-year-old patient, gravida 1, para 0, with no notable medical history, was referred to the department at 25 weeks of gestation for a fetal unilateral lower limb malformation. The pregnancy was otherwise uncomplicated and the mother did not take any medication and there were no previous maternal infectious diseases. Ultrasound examination at her first visit at 12 weeks, revealed a single viable fetus with a normal amount of amniotic fluid and nuchal translucency. Ultrasound examination at 24 weeks revealed a single viable fetus with measurements consistent with gestational age. Amniotic fluid was normal. Abnormalities, all located on the right lower limb, included unilateral agenesis of the fibula, hypoplastic tibia and unilateral club-foot with three metatarsa bones (Figure N°1-3).

Figure N°1 :
Longitudinal ultrasound scan of the 24 week fetus showing abnormal posturing of the right lower legs with club–foot deformities and absence of the fibula.

Figure N°2 :
Sonography of the right leg only, showing the absence of fibula and
confirming the hypoplasia of the tibia.

Figure N°3 :
3D sonography of the right leg.


The thumbs appeared to be normal as the reminder of the anatomic survey was normal. After the parents were informed by a pediatric orthopedic surgeon about the risks and the future handicaps for the neonate, they decided to continue the pregnancy. The fetal karyotype was normal. The baby was born at 38 weeks. Neonatal examination revealed a short right lower extremity (Figure N°4).

Figure N°4 :
Postnatal visualisation confirming the abnormalities located on the lower right limb in front of view (a) and lateral view (b).


The left foot, the arms and the fingers were normal. Neonatal X-rays of the skeletons radiographs confirmed unilateral absence of the fibula (Figure N°5). The right feet was clubbed and there was two toes and two metatarsal bones. The therapeutic project is the amputation of the right leg.

Figure N°5 :
Skeletal radiograph at one day of age confirming unilateral fibula hypoplasia. The malformation of the foot and the tibial anomalie are clearly seen in front of view (a) and lateral view (b).


Fibular hemimelia is a congenital deficiency or absence of the fibula. There is a spectrum of disease from mild fibular hypoplasia to fibular aplasia. The ipsilateral tibia may be hypoplastic, bowed or normal 3-4.Fibular hemimelia can be frequently associated with proximal focal femoral deficiency, deficiencies of the lateral aspect of the foot, or is part of a malformation syndrome 4. The syndrome caused by congenital absence of the fibula has another number of frequently associated pathologic abnormalities, which are illustrated by the case reported.
The syndrome "congenital absence of fibula" is also called: 

  • Femur-fibula-ulna syndrome 
  • Intercalary hemimelia of the fibula
  • Fibula, congenital deficiency of proximal femoral focal deficiency 
  • Congenital short tibia with absent or dysplastic fibula 5.

Usually sporadic (the recurrence risk for the patient’s siblings is negligible), although a familial incidence (autosomal recessive) has been reported in a small percentage of cases 6-7.Embryologic studies indicate a development insult to the embryo at about the fifth or sixth week of intrauterine life.Fibula abnormalities vary from a partial absence, with relatively normal-appearing limbs, to absent fibula, with marked shortening of the femur, curved tibia and serious foot anomalies.

Generally three types of congenital absence of fibula have been recognized.

TYPE I: Includes cases with unilateral or partial absence of the fibula, with mild or no bowing of the tibia (10 % of the cases). The leg may or may not be shortened.

TYPE II: Patients have unilateral absence of the fibula, anterior bowing of the tibia with dimpling foot deformity with absent rays, and marked shortening of the leg. This form is observed in about 35 % of the cases.

TYPE III: The remaining 55 % of the patients have unilateral or bilateral absence of the fibula, with the same leg and foot deformities above described and multiple other skeletal defects.

The diagnosis of congenital absence of fibula is made by the absence of the fibula with commonly associated clubfoot. When associated, tibial bowing and foot deformities are probably the result of abnormal attachments of the fibular muscles, resulting in abnormal stresses on the developing tibia and the foot, respectively. Other findings can also be diagnosed 9-10.

The most common associated anomaly is proximal femoral deficiency syndrome 11. Other anomalies includes

  • cardiac anomalies,
  • thrombocytopenia absent-radius (TAR) syndrome
  • thoraco-abdominal schisis
  • spina bifida and
  • renal anomalies 12-13

but most associated anomalies are skeletal and includes :

  • Peromelia (severe anomalies of distal limbs including absence of hand or foot)
  • congenital dislocation of the head of the radius 13
  • craniosynostosis
  • syndactyly
  • brachydactyly and
  • clinodactyly of fingers and toes and facial dysmorphism.

Fibular agenesis/hypoplasia is the most common reduction malformation affecting the long bones. Nevetheless agenesis of both the fibulae, however, is rare. The degree of fibular deficiency ranges from unilaterally short to bilaterally absent. A case of occurrence in four consecutive pregnancies has been reported once 14.

Differential diagnoses are easily eliminated as amniotic band syndrome, campomelic dysplasia, mesomelic dysplasia and other skeletal dysplasias with asymmetrical involvement of the lower limbs as Femoral-facies syndrome (FFS). Fetal thalidomide syndrome must be eliminated too15.

Nevertheless the differentiation of two forms is more difficult with these one :Femur-fibula-ulna complex (FFU) is not concidered because generally there is asymetrical femoral hypoplasia and hypoplasia of both tibiae and malformation of the hand16.

Sporadic non-lethal skeletal dysostosis, the spectrum of malformations is hightly variable, with no disorder being common to all patients.

Tibial hemimelia syndrome (THS) encompasses several types of syndrome, all of them involving tibial agenesis or hypoplasia and polydactyly17. Variable expressions of these clinical findings have been described. THS is associated with bilateral tibial agenesis, clubbing and polysyndactyly of the feet and five triphalangeal finger hands. Unlike bilateral hemimelia syndrome, a rare autosomal dominant condition, unilateral tibial hypoplasia is rarely described.The present case emphasizes the importance of establishing a correct antenatal diagnosis as an essential basis for genetic counseling essentially for subsequent pregnancies and treatment.

Prognosis is good with regard to mental development and life span.  So the prognosis is mainly dependant on the severity of the limb malformation and the possibility of orthopedic surgery16. Rehabilitation varies depending on the severity of the limb deficiency. Standard obstetrical management is not altered. Fibular deficiency is usually benign, but leg length inequality may be corrected by epiphysiodesis, leg lengthening, ankle
reconstruction using the Gruca technique18 or simply a shoe raise. Postsurgical therapy on the involved extremity should take into account the patient"s lack of joint motion within the tarsal region. With this in mind, special shoes or accommodative insoles, alone or in combination, should be prescribed in order to facilitate an increase in weightbearing activity with minimal discomfort. Rarely when the foot is nonfunctional, amputation may be considered19.

The treatment aimed simply to equalise leg length in Type I deficiency, while amputation of the foot and the fitting of a prosthesis were necessary in Type II to obtain satisfactory function20. In France, termination of pregnancy for medical reasons are accepted if gestation is potentially dangerous for the mother or when fetal malformations are lethal and or incurable. In our case, the pediatric orthopedic surgeons confirmed that the limb defect could not totally cured, leaving the child with a permanent limp even after several operations. The parents were offered an opportunity to meet a young boy treated for the same conditions and they opted for continuation of pregnancy.

The syndrome caused by congenital absence of the fibula has a number of pathologic abnormalities frequently associated with it, which are illustrated by the case reported. The parents must be advised that baby’legs amputation is possible even intellectual pronostic is normal.

1- Castilla E.E., Cavalcanti D.P., Dutra M.G., Lopez-camelo J.S., Pae J.E., Gadow E.G.- Limb reduction defects in south americ. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 1995, 102 : 393-400.
2- Stoll C., Alembik Y., Dott B., Roth M.P.- Evaluation of prenatal diagnosis of limb reduction defects by a registery of congenital anomalies. Prenat Diagn 1994 ; 14 : 781-6.
3- Sepulveda W., Weiner E., Bridger J.E., Fisk N.M.- Prenatal diagnosis of congenital absence of the fibula. J Ultrasound Med 1994 ; 13 : 655-7.
4-  Fordham L.A., Applegate K.E., Wilkes D.C., Chung C.J.- Fibular Hemimelia : More than just an absent bone. Semin Musculoskelet Radiol 1999 ; 3 : 227-38.
5- Parada S., Jeanty P.- 2001-01-19-16 Congenital absence of fibula-Parada
6- Gupta A.K., Berry M., Verma I.C.- Congenital absence of both fibulae in four siblings. Pediatr Radiol 1994 ; 24 : 220-1.
7- Kohn G., Veder M., Schoenfeld A., El Shawwa R.- New type of autosomal recessive short-limb dwarfism with absent fibulae, exceptionally short digits, and normal intelligence. Am J Med Genet 1989 ; 34 : 535-40.
8- Stanitski D.F., Stanitski C.L.- Fibular hemimelia : a new classification  system. J Pediatr Orthop 2003 ; 23 : 30-4.
9- Khurana D.K., Bhargava S.P.- Congenital absence of fibulae, with equinovarus deformity-a case report. Acta Orthop Scand 1997 ; 68 : 307-8.
10- Rizk D.E., Bates A., Evans J.- Isolated complex limb reduction abnormality diagnosed antenatally. Eur J Obstet Gynecol Reprod Biol 1993 ; 51 : 163-6.
11- Capece G., Fasolino A., Della Monica M., Lonardo F., Scarano G., Neri G.- Prenatal diagnosis of femur-fibula-ulna complex by ultrasonography in a male fetus at 24 weeks of gestation. Prenat Diagn 1994 ; 14 : 502-5.
12- Pivnick E.K., Kaufman R.A., Velagaleti G.V., Gunther W.M., Abramovici D.- Infant with midline thoracoabdominal schisis and limb defects. Teratology 1998 ; 58 : 205-8.
13-  Cuervo M., Albinana J., Cebrian J., Juarez C.- Congenital hypoplasia of the fibula : clinical manifestations. J Pediatr Orthop B 1996 ; 1 : 35-8
14- Gupta A.K., Berry M., Verma I.C.- Congenital absence of both fibulae in four siblings. Pediatr Radiol 1994 ; 24 : 220-1.
15- Florio I., Wisser J., Huch R., Huch A.- Prenatal ultrasound diagnosis of a Femur-Fibula-Ulna complex during the first half of preganncy. Fetal Diagn Ther 1999 ; 14 : 310-2.
16- Geipel A., Berg C., Germer U., Krokowski M., Smrcek J.,, Gembruch
U.- Prenatal diagnosis of femur-fibula-ulna complex by ultrasound examination at 20 weeks of gestation. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2003 ; 22 : 79-81.
17- Dreyfus M., Baldauf J.J., Rigaut E., Clavert J.M., Gasser B., Ritter J.- Prenatal diagnosis of unilateral tibial hemimelia. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 1996 ; 7 : 205-7.
18- Thomas I.H., Williams P.F.- The Gruca operation for congenital absence of the fibula. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1987 ; 69 : 587-92
19- Maffulli N., Fixsen J.A.- Management of forme fruste fibular hemimelia. J Pediatr Orthop B 1996 ; 5 : 17-9
20- Achterman C., Kalamchi A.- Congenital deficiency of the fibula. J Bone Joint Surg Br 1979 ; 61-B : 133-7.

Help Support :